Ernest Marsh wrote:
While you have all come up with valid arguments as to why the scheme wont work - you have missed one point.
Some young drivers will wish to save some money and WONT want to drive at night, so the scheme WILL work for them.
Perhaps .. but you can never guarantee an emergency.
As said - had student job .. was nights. Had to work A&E as student and as newly qualified junior. Was thus on road at these times. Student medics and those working as bar men and maids .. or even shelf stackers at the 24 hour supermarkets will find they make zero savings on this. Will tempt - but I would warn kids who work the night shift at the 24 hour shops and petrol stations to be wary. £25 per night is more than your pay check for the night shift worked. False economy and possible acquiescence to "spy in the boot fo all and even pay as you go".
40% reduction? "More than" like 100% hike up on already high prices.
SHOP AROUND. Most offer better deals than this one.
Most offer better deals and
freedom of mobility 
You may ifind the competition "more than lucky!"

Quote:
I assume students who like to go out at night would take a taxi if they were going to have a drink!
I never did take a taxi. I used to stagger with my mates into an an establishment called "Charleez" or some such name and get sober with some concoction called a "suicide"

I do recall that it took to lining from your mouth as you attempted to eat it
Then we'd stagger to whoever's digs were nearest and fall asleep!
Er... and you thought all medical students did was learn anatomy.. er..

Better not let my wife know about things like that
Quote:
I have worked nights or driven late all my life, so I have never joined Cumbria's "Vehicle Watch" scheme, but I would not discourage others from taking part!
Same here
Quote:
However, those who are working unsociable hours could be earning a wage, and should shop around for a better offer - such as those that offer to allow named drivers on others insurance to accumulate their own NCD!
I dont think it will lead to widespread fraud - just the occasional chancer who probably already chances his arm with a few fibs on his proposal form.
Night shift at the 24 hour supermarkets. I know a lot to be students, Some are our twins' class mates. As said .. William has a shift job - works nights every now and then.
Nick and Steff - more or less getting work experience in the seasonal tourist trade.
Quote:
MORE THAN are simply trying a new wrinkle to attract customers.
I have recently taken up Admiral's "Dual Vehicle" policy, which allows me to insure both mine and my wife's car on one synchronised policy for a substantial saving. I really took it up because I like the parrot in their advert!

It could go more than pear shaped too.
Fortis seem to offer me a consistently "best lowest quote price deal" each year. I shop around - but they still offer me the lowest deal for my main family cars, my "toys" and now my three eldest.
