http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/news/66724 ... laims.html
[not sure if or when this will appear in the print edition]
Fury over M4 speed camera claims
A furious dispute has broken out over safety claims made by the Wiltshire and Swindon Speed Camera Partnership, the body responsible for speed cameras on the M4.
The camera partnership claimed to have reduced accidents on the M4 by between 44 and 57 percent by use of their mobile speed camera vans.
The Association of British Drivers and the Safe Speed campaign reject the claim, by pointing out that only 15 percent of accidents on the M4 had excess speed as their cause, and many of these were still not breaking the limit, despite their speed being excessive for the conditions.
"There's something very odd going on here," said the ABD's Director of Policy Mark McArthur-Christie. "We have a speed camera partnership claiming credit for reducing accidents that weren't even caused by speeding. This seems disingenuous at best."
"The camera partnership is taking credit for falls in deaths - but the fatality rate from 2005 was identical to that in 1999 and 2000 - despite the M4 cameras only starting operations in 2005."
"Our detailed analysis [shows] that inattention, failure to judge other drivers' speed and changing lanes without looking were the biggest killers on this stretch of road (accounting for 75% of fatal crashes), not speed."
Meanwhile Safe Speed campaigner Paul Smith had a much stronger reaction to the claims: I am absolutely incensed that, once again, a camera partnership is making outrageous and unjustified claims for their cameras based on insufficient data and insufficient analysis. Misleading road safety statistics are deadly. They cause life-saving resources to be allocated to the wrong areas, and we therefore miss the opportunity to save lives".
He went on to point out that after 14 years of speed cameras on UK roads, and despite £800 million of fines issued to 13 million motorists, the UK has the slowest-improving road safety record in Europe.