http://www.carkeys.co.uk/news/2006/june/28/10437.asp
http://www.itv-motoring.com/news/2006/june/28/10437.asp
Are Our Roads Safer Or Not?
(Wed 28 Jun 06)
Two motoring organisations have reacted immediately to a report published in the British Medical Journal on the subject of death and serious injury on English roads. The report has been compiled by Mike Gill of the South East Public Health Group and Michael Goldacre and David Yeates of Oxford University's Department of Health, and it contrasts Department of Transport statistics with hospital admission figures.
The result of the research shows that although police figures suggest that the number of people killed or seriously unjured in road accidents fell sharply from 85.9 per 100,000 in the population in 1996 to 59.4/100,000 in 2004, hospital admission rates for traffic injuries remained virtually constant at 90.0/100,000 in 1996 and 91.1/100,000 in 2004 (with a very slight downward trend if you take into account the figures for the years in between).
The conclusion of the report is that "the overall fall seen in police statistics for non-fatal road traffic injuries probably represents a fall in completeness of reporting of these injuries". In other words, nothing to do with road transport policy.
The Association of British Drivers and Safe Speed are both vehemently opposed to current road transport policy, and they have both been quick to formulate their responses. "Despite millions spent on humps, calming, cameras and campaigns, our roads are not getting safer," says the ABD's Director of Policy, Mark McArthur-Christie. "Simplicity, soundbites and political expediency have been allowed to dictate a road safety policy that is more concerned with legality than safety.
"These figures show we need finally to acknowledge that safe driving is about so much more than speed. What about observation? What about anticipation? What about hazard management? We need thinking, trained and educated drivers and road users, not simply ones who believe that speed limit compliance is the pinnacle of driving-skill achievement."
Safe Speed road safety campaign founder Paul Smith is equally vehement. "Department for Transport has a dangerously oversimplified view of road safety," he says. "Despite over a decade of ever-increasing speed controls the roads have not got safer. My extensive research reveals that DfT policy is making drivers worse. We're spending far too much time concentrating on the wrong safety factors - and DfT is responsible.
"I've know for three years that the serious injury statistics were behaving very strangely in relation to other road safety indicators. The only possible conclusion was that changes in the figures were an artefact of the reporting process. The new BMJ paper provides very strong additional evidence."
If you want to read the paper (which is crammed full of information but takes up only three pages) it can be found at
http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/rapidpdf ... 1.4Fv1.pdf. The ABD and Safe Speed's online presence are at
www.abd.org.uk and
www.safespeed.org.uk respectively.