http://news.scotsman.com/scotland.cfm?id=954082006
Poll 'blames' the public for voting against congestion fee
ALASTAIR DALTON
TRANSPORT CORRESPONDENT
EDINBURGH'S rejection of congestion charging was a knee-jerk reaction by ill-informed residents who did not trust the city council and thought traffic problems were caused by outsiders, according to new Scottish Executive research.
But the findings were last night branded "outrageous" for "blaming" voters for rejecting the scheme.
The first official study since last year's emphatic referendum result also reveals that men were more supportive of the £2-a-day charge than women, while there was less backing among older residents than younger people.
The Labour-led city council pronounced its plans "dead and buried" after they were rejected in February last year by 133,678 votes to 45,965 - nearly three to one.
The new study, by pollsters MORI, found residents quickly formed their views about the scheme, but often were unaware of, or misunderstood, details.
They also found that people accepted the need to tackle congestion and air pollution, but disagreed that they should have to pay to tackle them. Those questioned also blamed motorists driving into the city rather than residents for causing the problem. The study concluded: "Residents had made their minds up quite soon after they heard about the scheme and this was not based on a detailed understanding of the proposal, but on a reaction to the idea of paying to use Edinburgh roads.
"Many held misconceptions about how it would operate, the amount of the charge and the specific location of the charging zones. Unfortunately, few actively sought information and widespread misconceptions remained."
The researchers, who questioned 1,002 people last autumn, found lack of trust "was an underlying driver of opposition". Over a third of residents felt that the council was anti-car.
But Paul Smith, founder of the independent Safe Speed Campaign, commented on the report: "It's outrageous for politicians to blame the people of Edinburgh for rejecting congestion charges. It shows they are simply not prepared to listen to the opinion of people.
"Motorists were right to reject congestion charges because most of these schemes are fundamentally flawed."
Fred Mackintosh, a Lib Dem councillor, said: "It was the council's fault the scheme was spectacularly complicated and people misunderstood it."
Iain Whyte, the council's Conservative group leader, said: "The council was out of touch, and despite holding three public consultations and sending out huge amounts of information, those selling it had no credibility."
Andrew Burns, the council's executive member for transport, who spearheaded the scheme, said tackling congestion remained a key target.