http://www.askaprice.com/torque-article ... &item=1848
Speed Cameras statistics clash
The Department for Transport were accused yesterday of failing to manage road safety properly and effectively after hospital figures and police statistics directly contradicted each other on the efficiency of speed cameras at reducing serious injuries and death.
Although official police statistics show the number of people seriously injured or killed on the UK´s roads falling consistently from 85.9 per 100,000 in 1996 to 59.4 per 100,000 in 2004, hospital admission statistics for the same period show no drop in admissions for traffic injuries, and in some cases, the numbers actually increased. During this period use of roadside cameras saw a massive increase, and researchers have been checking statistics to find the effects of their introduction.
Paul Smith of road safety group Safe Speed spoke out angrily to the Daily Express, accusing The Department for Transport of using flawed statistics to justify a failing policy.
But can it be true that the £1billion speed camera industry has had no real effect on increasing the safety of our roads? Costing £750million to install and landing 2million motorists with fines last year alone, it would be embarrassing for the government to backtrack on the cameras and would also leave a huge gap in revenue. The number of cameras has ballooned to 3,300 fixed sites and 3,400 mobile devices, and the police figures show a significant drop. So what cause the discrepancy?
The police figures are compiled by police officers at the scene of traffic accidents. But Oxford University students carried out a survey that found that that hospital admission rates for traffic injuries contradicted those statistics, by actually showing a slight rise of 1.1 incidents in every 100,000 (from 90 to 91.1) in the period under scrutiny.
According to the researchers recordings in the British Medical Journal, it would seem that the fall seen in the police statistics could be attributed to inconsistencies in the reporting process. According to Mr Smith, the NHS data is likely to be closer to the true figure, as their system for reporting is more robust - representing events and decisions made under medical consideration when compared to checking a tickbox on a police report form.
However, the Association of Chief Police Officers were happy to stand by their figures last night, and denied that their policies were not working, going as far as to say that there was no doubt road safety had improved, and regardless of under-reporting deaths continued to go down.