FJSRiDER wrote:
In Gear wrote:
FJSRiDER wrote:
my point is that since compulsion in 83(?) the total numbers of KSI have not decreased significantly.
Due to a lot of reasons - Europe are stricter on j-walking and observing I am always struck by the way they cross roads. You can tell a Brit tourist a mile off - talking loudly in English and crossing where none of the locals do!
Segregated cycle paths are also more prevalent there - helps the cyclists and they do use them. But then those paths are not sop tokens to meet some target.
Neither of these are different HERE (in the UK) since the introduction of seat belts though.....
But we appear to have reduced deaths for the occupants - you did say somewhere above that people without the car as opposed to within the car were in more danger owing to "risk taking behaviour per some pen psuhing researcher in an ivory tower somewhere
Quote:
In Gear wrote:
Dumbing down in general seems to be part of the symptoms.
I agree. We need people to think through the consequences of their actions on the roads.
Why DIS/Speed Awares and courses for drink drivers immediatelly or at completion of ban have been introduced.
I would be happier if there was some kind of refresher for all. In-service training is given in most professions and skills. I do not see why driving and cycling should not have this same "booster jab" from time to time. I think it would motivate and encourage that elsuive "pride" in driving to best of personal ability/capability at all times.
Quote:
In Gear wrote:
FJSRiDER wrote:
I am interested in the the 'stats' of the total number of road user casualties for the period from the adoption of seatbelts (late 60's?) to the present day.
Was there a drop in the totals in early '80's following the introduction of compulsion or not?
We seemed to follow the same steady overall downward trend in general - but the introduction of the belts was not the prime cause of the increased KSI at the time. Series of bad winters did not help and even this may have skewed some of these results as well.
You seem to be agreeing with me. The introduction of seat belts has NOT reduced the numbers of KSI on the roads.
The stats have always shown a steady decrease year on year - until last 8 years or so when they seem to have stuck around the 3500 mark nationally.
Seat belts have played some part in the reduction since 1982 to current levels. But other factors such as car design, engineering out some blackspots have also been equally significant. They have all combined to some extent.
Our real problem is really all road user
attitude and hazard perception skills . As folk become more reliant on technology and let's face it - modern bikes are a hell of a lot easier to ride - they lose out on developing that all important basic human "danger alert sense" I also think that the computer and microwave lifestyle is also creating impatience and a tendency to skim over instead of paying attention to details.
I am not sure how we can remedy this. I also think part of the problem is also linked to the "loving neglect" which the teacher union boss mentioned this week. Over molly coddling ... these kids are given a computer and telly for a "babysitter"

They are - per these expert educators - not developing social skills, the art of communication and negotiation, judgement .... and this could also be falling over into an inabilty to judge danger of an approaching car or bicycle with any kind of accuracy.
There are a lot of factors - we are barely scratching the surface in real terms.
Quote:
In Gear wrote:
We seem to be seeing a level remaining at a high despite seat belts and speed cams - lot of it down to society's attitudes and overall complacency.
Where do you think this 'complacency' comes from?
I suspect the drip, drip,drip of 'safety benefits' and 'driver aids' that remove the need for the road user to think much about what they are doing.
See above.
Wildy posted a long time back on PH that over reliance on gadgets seemed to undermine skill. I think she made a reply to a chap over on PH that using these gadgets effectively means developing a different skill strategy... she decided you would have to understand exactly what this technology was trying to offer in order to use effectively - enhancing existing skills without compromising them.
Quote:
In Gear wrote:
cars manufacturers developed a number of measures to protect occupants in vehicles as we all know.
In the event of a pedestiran hit at 30 mph - we do find the car's crumple zone does cause less damage to the pedestrian and this has been played on quite a bit as we know
But the wearing of seatbelts is not causing recklessness. Lot of the "kill drivers" who are illegal in the first place do not wear the belts and drive like t

s.
Accidents are caused as pointed numerous times by driver not being as observant as he should be, slow to pereceive a hazard on the one hand - and the other party also not applying some safety led vigilance.
Dismissing a safety feature by claiming it makes the driver reckless (and there is next to no proof of this and most certainly nothing "peer reviewed") hardly protects anyone

I did not suggest that 'the wearing of seatbelts is causing recklessness' or 'dismiss' the using of them. I said that the use of them (and other 'safety aids') can cause the effect observed in Risk Homeostasys theory.
But there is no real proof. The Lancet piece you offer does not provide any real proof. There are more articles - publiched Doctorate dissertations and so on - which support efficiency of seat belts and which do not support the Homeostassy theroy in this respect.
Quote:
You have pretty much confirmed my impression that since the introduction of seatbelts the numbers of those KSI'd overall has not dropped. Therefore I think it pretty apalling that you boast that you will harrass and harangue drivers who you catch not using them.
They, like 'crash' helmets, do very little at all to save lives.
My lads and lasses are paid to enforce the law. They can use discretioanry powers within professional reason. We do not harrasss or harangue anyone.

But we have a duty to point out the dangers of not wearing them and fine if we have to
KSI is still low compared to other areas in our patch. We are not that much different to anywhere else. We are visible and known to be visible. We try to prevent incidents around here.... we talk to our drivers, advise our drivers. I think they take notice. We don't always issue fines - a friendly chat or even a gesture to belt up or switch on lights can work just the same. You can tell whether an oversight or deliberate
But you cannot say they "do little to save lives" based on one article written over 6 years ago in the Lancet - when more evidence overall exists to suggest the contrary.
For example - just to annoy the Mad Doc as he's had to fork out for car seats for three of his kids in the 5- 12 years bracket - TRL and EU evidence exists to show child injury is less if in a child seat than if not secured in one. His argument is that this evidence of damage to internal organs in the event of a crash is very prevalent for little ones and not tall 11 year olds!

Can sympathise - but Ted mate - you know I did offer some suggestions....
