I have had a reply from the pcc and the mirror and the
government 5th report dealing with motor cycle evasion
It is quite horrifying the tone of the submissions and replys that there are tax payers and criminals.
Quote:
I refer to your letter of 1 February 2008 which has been passed to me for my attention.
Paul Routledge wrote his article based on reports of the Evasion of Vehicle Excise Duty report by the House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts.
Please see attached paragraph 7 of the Conclusion and Recommendations. Whether 40% of motorcyclists at any time are evading tax whilst riding on the road is irrelevant. The Committee are concerned that nearly 40% of motorcyclists are evading tax. If somebody • keeps their motorcycle in the garage without paying tax and without notifying the proper authorities, that is an evasion of tax.
Please also find attached articles from The Times and Daily Mail newspapers on this subject.
In the circumstances, given that the report did not distinguish between on and off road tax evasion, Paul Routledge took care not to publish inaccurate information.
Consequently, there was breach of the Code. Yours sincerely
My draft reply
Quote:
Thankyou for your letter and submissions from The Mirror and the attached parlementry report.
I am a little confused by the mirror response
Paul Motteram lays down a defence then admits guilt. Is that what he meant to type?
“consequentualy there was a breach of code”
The mirror article was factually wrong.
It stated that 40% of motorcycles on the road were tax evading. Not in sheds
Over half of these people never ride their bikes on the road and have got in a mess with their paperwork and are law abiding people criminalised by the complexity and errors of the system. ( a system that makes you criminal for forgetting to return paperwork where 15%+ are dyslexic men(like me!) To see how complex taxing cars and bikes see my comments in below.
The second point he made was that motorcyclists should pay a year in advance for tax. If he had done simple research he would have found friends or contacts with motorbikes who would have told him that tax is paid in advance. He appears to have taken the official line with out looking for the counter argument which he should do as a good journalist. As a result he posted a story that makes car drivers hate motorcyclists even more.
Therefore I do not accept that he took care not to publish inaccurate information.
I believe he used just one source of information to write this report and got the wrong end of the stick.
The House of commons report.
To Paul’s defence I was shocked by the emphasis of the document supplied that believes there are tax payers and criminals. The whole document represented a different world that I have experienced where almost every motoring restorer or enthusiast has a tale to tell about the DVLA and road tax.
I my self have 4 cars at home. 1 taxed, 1 tax exempt disabled, 1 untaxed as it has not been on the road since 1985, and a 4th untaxed and unregistered as I cannot register it because it is a class c write off waiting a repair and vic test. Every single one is 100% legal. Of the two untaxed, neither are sorn’d as they cannot be sorn'd or taxed. One cannot be registered. The disabled class car had to be registered taxed, re-registered, wait for a cert and re-taxed which failed online & by phone because dvla failed to recognise my wife’s national insurance number we ended up paying 2months road tax whilst this all took place. The Westminster “muppetts” believe all tax failure is due to criminal behaviour. DVLA are in my eyes are hopeless, they are not efficient at sorting problems, issue on line tax forms that don’t work if you follow their wrong instructions. And their staff are unmotivated and have huge sick levels.
The way this report is written I am a double criminal, A member of the underclass! These civil servants’ in their Toyota Prius do not understand the electorate. With classic cars, motorbikes and an old moped in the shed. The people on this committee see their rich London life at one end and a criminal under class on a rough estate at the other end.
An untaxed car or bike in a shed that is sorn’d.. is not criminal!!! It is compliant legal behaviour.
I visit a lot of motoring forums and many people report sorn’ing cars and receiving fines or no reminder to repeat the sorn after 12 months. DVLA records are notoriously wrong.
The “criminal underclass” do not instantly rise 20% in one year. There must be a change in accounting methods in the DVLA or DFT. Or there has been a loss of records and reminders causing the public to make more errors.
There is a very simple way for the government to collect road tax. PUT IT ON FUEL!
However they would rather “criminalise” people.
The document does not mention the Millions of cars and bikes in the insurance process between a crash, auction, repair or crusher.
My sister’s car is another fine example. Owned from new 9 years old 100% legal but devalued down to about £2000. The engine blew. It is not a write off because the repair costs are about 75% of its value she sold it on to the trade. It will be out of the system for 3-12 months will it is fixed or becomes a donor vehicle for another to be fixed. Then it will be registered or crushed.
The other point is that the government believe we are criminals for not paying their road fund licence. Yet they are not criminal for spending a measly percentage of what is collected on the road system.
The other point is that the government are trying to justify their expenditure in a hugely expensive satellite tracking system and for some mad reasom want to bring in more complex road charging.
_________________
Speed limit sign radio interview. TV
Snap Unhappy“It has never been the rule in this country – I hope it never will be - that suspected criminal offences must automatically be the subject of prosecution” He added that there should be a prosecution: “wherever it appears that the offence or the circumstances of its commission is or are of such a character that a prosecution in respect thereof is required in the public interest”
This approach has been endorsed by Attorney General ever since 1951. CPS Code