handy wrote:
SafeSpeed wrote:
This is highly visible on motorways. Few drivers need the 70mph limit. Few driver observe the 70mph limit in good conditions. But would I want a 17 year old driver in his first (old) car driving at 80mph in poor conditions?
Me, earlier today wrote:
If the speed limits were correct (and variable to allow for changing conditions)
I think the inexperience and condition of the car are actually part of the conditions.
Sure. That's useful. But you're coming my way because obviously those factors cannot be included in a speed limit.
Add in variable traffic conditions, perhaps a road with clear straights, junctions and bends, a bit of wild weather and any attempt at useful speed limits starts to look a bit lame. Even variable speed limits have no chance of keeping up.
handy wrote:
SafeSpeed wrote:
I sincerely believe that discretionary enforcement is the only possible answer.
even more of an "Yikes" than JtB above ... I think we are in some sort of agreement here? The difference between my position and yours is purely one of timing - setting the acceptable limits for the overall conditions of the system happens before the 'speeding' event, discretionary enforcement happens after the 'speeding' event.
How did this happen? I'll have to post something soon to redress the balance

Come on over. Everything makes sense over here...