Squirrel wrote:
My last 3 cars have been fitted with ESP (stability control). It's prevented an accident on at least 2 occasions.
Coming round a fast bend in an NSL section of B-road I hit a patch of spilled diesel. The car ended up going sideways for about half a second, I ended up on the wrong side of the road - but the ESP kicked in and regained control meaning that I was able to correct it.
Prior to hitting this diesel spill I was driving well within the limits of my car, the road and my own ability. This was in a 2003 A4 Quattro 1.9 TDI 130.
Similarly in the car I have now (2006 A4 Quattro 2.0 TDI 170) I came round a bend one night on another B-road in torrential rain doing less than 40mph and ploughed straight into standing water. The car nearly spun when all 4 wheels aquaplaned, but the ESP straightened it out once it had slowed enough to regain traction. This was late at night and I had no way of seeing the standing water.
But all these cars allow you to turn off the ESP. Indeed I've had to on a couple of occasions, eg when parked on a beach car park. Trying to pull away when you're parked on soft sand completely confuses the ESP and you end up going nowhere - so you have to be able to disable it.
Your experiences above are why I think esp systems are a good idea, they help improve primary safety. My problem is that while they are a good idea they are not actually any good in reality because they cut in far too early - at least on the cars I have driven. The system on my wife's BMW activates on the slightest hint of wheel spin or over steer, personally I find this disrupts the feel and balance of the car so it gets turned off more often than not. This means I have to compromise, losing the benefit of esp in an emergency situation to gain the safety in everyday driving by having good feel and control of the car.
Your final point is a strong argument against fully activated non-canceling esp becoming a legal requirement though an earlier post mentions a time limited switch off which would be a problem.
If an esp system does not allow at least a little slip then, again as an in above post, some drivers will not even realise they are starting to push the grip/traction budget of their cars and so overall safety may actually be lowered.