Yesterday's "MEN" 's headline (and carried by the tabloids today..
)
Salesman Keith P could not believe it when pulled in Warrington .. for tucking into his Cheshire cheese and pickle sandwich. He was told he had
Quote:
fallen foul of the tough new penalties for drivers holding handy held mobile phones.
Keith was given a producer and ordered to report at his nearest station with all his documents.. and was told that the new rules apply to eating and drinking behind the wheel as well as taking and receiving calls.
But.. OK.. apart from the odd sucky sweet or chocs.. I do not eat butties, cakes, apples or swig water or pop whilst driving. I happen to like a stop.. a leg stretch .. and usually I have eaten properly anyway .. I don;t need snacks as such. But ..
In all the hype over the hands held mobile phone laws .. I do not recall seeing that much to warn drivers that this also applied to taking a chomp from a Mars Bar whilst driving. (I concede that the Ploughman's Wedge per the press photo was a bit on "big side"
) .
Keith wrote:
In my mind I was completely in control of the vehicle. You see other people putting on their make-up behind the wheel
I bet that got the female support. (He's only young.. aged 29. Word of advice.. if you value your life.. don't tell wimmin about time taken to put on make-up
I have sisters .. they once thumped me for removing the light bulbs in their rooms.
when we were in our teens/early twenties
)
Not my wife though .. she does not need much make-up beyond "traditonal" lippy anyway
(Have to say that or
she'll claw me
)
Keith in a right cheese and pickle wrote:
I've never been pulled over by the police before and I think 3 points on my licence is a bit much.
It seems Salford lad Keith was travelling between two supermarkets when he began to chomp at the £2 muffin. As he drove his company owned Astra along the A49 (Lythgoes Lane) .. he was caught in a police operation to "cop drivers on their phones!"
Keith getting into a cheese and pickle wrote:
The Cheshire policeman stepped in front of my car
Er .. that was a bit risky really..
Quote:
and pulled me over. He said I had committed an offence just as serious as chatting on my mobile. When I queried this.. he said eating and drinking at the wheel of a car was driving without due care and attention.
The paper reports that this penalty caused surprise when he produced his documents at his local (GMP) station. The officer behind the desk could not believe he had been given a fixed penalty for eating a muffin whilst driving.
IG had better stop calling himself a "stud muffin"
But the DfT claimed Cheshire police had acted "correctly" - telling reporter Alan Salter that
Quote:
you are not in control of the car if you are reading a map or eating and drinking at the wheel of the car. Reasearch by Dr Young of Brunel University in London says that the results of their experiment strongly indicate that eating and drinking whilst driving increases the risk of a crash
Not blipping over a speed limit then..
Quote:
Drivers may not perceive the risk to be any higher than any other car tasks .. but the impaired reactions combined with workloads suggest drivers should exert caution
Which is not the same thing as saying in concrete terms that eating .. say a pack of crisps or some sweeties .. causes an accident. Just that it could compromise COAST skills and thus perhaps increase risk marginally
A Handy phone is different in that concentration is taken by holding the pesky thing to the ear .. and concentrating on the conversation - which is not the same as with person in the car with you.
I personally would not eat a sandwich or anything like whilst driving as I like to enjoy my food.. but do have the odd sucky sweet.
I comment more the less than conclusive and probably even "out of context" extract from the research - not by the journalist who is perhaps reporting from his interview notes -
but by the DfT (Perhaps Paul might like to ask the journalist for this source ..for his research purposes. )
Cheshire police meanwhile defend their action:
Cheshire police in the Manchester paper wrote:
Much publicity has been given to the recent changes in penalties for using a mobile phone whilst driving. The law also covers offences relating to not being in proper control of their vehicles and not concentrating on the road.
This covers anything which takes concentration from the road. and increases the dangers to others on the roads Drivers need to be aware that they are liable to a fixed penalty if anything diverts their attention from the road
Well.. we have always blathered on about C in COAST
but even so.. Whilst C also stands for Courtesy/consideration which complement the "relaxed concentration" - it also stands for basic COMMON SENSE!
Whilst I do not condone Keith's chomping away at a wedge of what I normally associate with "cardboard" (He did say it was not a particularly good butty in the nationals
) - I do think that given the emphasis on the phone issue .. and perhaps a lack of awareness that this also includes eating a butty at the wheel.. justice in this instance might have been better served by pointing this nuance in interpretation of this law to him.. and spelling out COAST properly to him.