weepej wrote:
In common with any feature designed to reduce injury there will always be exceptions. Airbags and seatbelts kill people for instance, so do motorcycle helmets and saftey glass, and I've no doubt that somebody has been killed plowing into a speed camera pole before now, but in general they increase safety.
Same with chicanes.
http://www.dft.gov.uk/pgr/roads/tpm/tal ... ge=2#a1006No they don't! When did you last see a seat belt kick someone to death? NONE of these devices (except, perhaps, airbags that miss-fire and kill mechanics working in the footwell) actually "kill" people. Poor driving kills people.
In your previous post, you applaud the use of chicaines because you think that the drivers of the cars that collide with one another deserve all they get and that it will teach them a lesson.
But here's a stange thing!
When did you last see two cars hit each other head-on in a chicaine where EITHER of them was exceeding the speed limit? I've seen the odd bump at a chicaine before now and I can assure you that neither car would have been doing anything LIKE 30 MPH on impact! You think that putting these things up will stop people speeding - and I'm sure they they do. (Well, at that point anyway). And yet, we've probably all seen accidents at these "safety" features that are litle more than parking knocks! Of course, I agree that at least one driver in each of these situations will be guilty of SOME sort of motoring offence - but speeding? I very much doubt it!
So one has to ask oneself, do these so-called "safety" features, actually cause more accidents than they prevent? If I were a cynical person, I might be tempted to observe that such minor accidents would not generate any KSIs and would therefore not concern the local SCP's data at all!