Safe Speed issued the following PR at 04:28 this morning.
PR408: Gender difference claims dangerously misleading says Safe Speed
news: for immediate release
Research from Brunel University misinforms the road safety debate with absurd
foundation assumptions says Safe Speed. Attitudes to road safety and safe
driving are not the same as attitudes to speed limit enforcement.
The increasingly obsessive enforcement of speed limits has not improved road
safety. This is why the Safe Speed campaign exists. We believe that road safety
is highly dependent on the skills and attitudes of road users, with only 1 in
20 crashes involving a vehicle exceeding a speed limit we need to look
elsewhere for road safety improvements.
Paul Smith, founder of the Safe Speed road safety campaign
(
www.safespeed.org.uk) said: "It is ludicrous to equate attitudes to speed
enforcement with attitudes to road safety, yet this is the foundation of the
absurd claims made by Claire Corbett. I am angry because this sort of nonsense
will misinform the road safety debate and ultimately cost lives. Dr Corbett is
commenting on the law and its enforcement without considering the possibility
that legal behaviour and safe behaviour are not the same."
"Everyone knows that it is important that people don't 'drive too fast', but
the speed limit is only a proxy for the desired safe behaviour. It plays a very
minor role in drivers' risk management. Drivers who prefer the proxy measure to
setting a safe speed according to the conditions are inherently dangerous. Yet
current policy is making many more of these drivers. No wonder road deaths
haven't fallen as expected in the speed camera era."
The Press release announcing the paper from Brunel University states:
"Academics call for policymakers to consider womens views as well as mens."
Paul Smith called this an "extraordinary error", and explained: "We must have
road safety policies which are based on sound evidence and analysis, not
uninformed opinion. Sound evidence and analysis will not be perceived
differently by suitably qualified people whatever their sex."
"People seem to think the Safe Speed campaign is about the 'right to speed'.
Nothing could be further from the truth. The Safe Speed campaign demands road
safety policies that are based on sound evidence. Basic examination of road
safety data soon highlights that the system is not working near the threshold
where marginal difference in speed limit compliance could be expected to show a
road safety benefit. For example:
With 5% of crashes involving a speeding vehicle out of about 200,000 injury
crashes in a year, we have about 10,000 crashes involving speeding each year
amongst 32 million licenced drivers. A simple division reveals that the average
driver goes 3,200 years before he causes a crash involving speeding. Yet
Department for Transport figures tell us that speeding is endemic with around
60% of vehicles speeding on most road types. They have yet to explain how it is
that speeding is so dramatically under-represented in the crash statistics."
<ends>