Safe Speed Forums

The campaign for genuine road safety
It is currently Fri Nov 20, 2026 14:23

All times are UTC [ DST ]




Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 1 post ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: Tue Nov 28, 2006 05:54 
Offline
Site Admin
User avatar

Joined: Sat Mar 06, 2004 06:46
Posts: 16903
Location: Safe Speed
http://news.scotsman.com/politics.cfm?id=1727842006

Minister hints at decision on new crossing before elections

COLIN DONALD AND EBEN HARRELL

THERE was confusion at the heart of the Scottish Executive last night over a new Forth crossing as Nicol Stephen, the Deputy First Minister, hinted at an early decision, only to be overruled by his officials.

Mr Stephen said there was now the prospect of movement on a second crossing before the May election. But Executive officials said it was not possible.

Business leaders last night attacked the mixed messages, saying it was "discouraging" and did nothing to deliver the certainty companies needed.

Meanwhile, The Scotsman's campaign for an immediate decision on a second crossing received the backing of major transport groups, including the AA and RAC.

Speaking at a conference on Fife's economy, Mr Stephen, the enterprise minister, said: "The decision was planned for May 2007 but, given the importance of the issue, it is possible that there could be progress before the election."

He added that Transport Scotland work on the site and design of a new crossing was progressing "speedily". Mr Stephen added: "If it were possible the work could be done sooner, we would not want to hang around until May."

But his statement was later contradicted by a spokeswoman for the Executive, who said it was "not feasibly possible" that the necessary information would be ready before the election. And a spokesman for Transport Scotland, the Executive's transport agency, insisted it was still working to the May deadline set by ministers.

Liz Cameron, the director of Scottish Chambers of Commerce, said Mr Stephen's comments did nothing to reassure the business community. "It is an easy option for politicians to make encouraging noises, but hints and confusion on the matter will not deliver the certainty business needs."

Hew Balfour, chief executive of the Fife shopfitters Havelock Europa, said: "It's pretty discouraging. Here is a government with a major problem that still doesn't know what its deliverables are."

The Scotsman's campaign for a new Forth bridge or tunnel yesterday gained the support of the AA Motoring Trust, RAC Foundation and the Association of British Drivers. The Freight Transport Association, the Safe Speed road safety campaign and the North Sea ferry operator Superfast Ferries all joined the campaign calling for an immediate decision on a replacement crossing.

The Forth Road Bridge was designed to carry a maximum of 12 million cars a year. It carries double that figure. On good days, traffic backs up a mile. During strong winds or after an accident, cars can often line up to five miles into Fife.

Neil Greig, of the AA Motoring Trust, said: "With rising congestion on both existing road and rail links, new infrastructure is needed to cope with the continued expansion of the economy in Fife and the Lothians. Corrosion on the Forth Road Bridge means an early decision is now needed."

Sheila Rainger, campaigns manager of the RAC Foundation, said: "We believe that the congestion on the current road bridge presents a barrier to mobility and restricts the development of Fife."

Delays due to high winds and temporary road repairs have become routine for regular users of the bridge.

A contraflow will operate for four months at weekends next year during resurfacing of the northbound carriageway.

Yesterday, the Forth Estuary Transport Authority added that other major repairs, including the replacement of the bridge's main expansion joints, will need to be completed within five years.

Engineers estimate replacing the main expansion joints will result in a three-week closure of one side of the bridge, leading to delays of up to several hours at peak times.

A spokesman for FETA said: "The bridge isn't getting any younger and many of its components will need replaced or repaired in the years ahead.

"Users Bridge face evermore frequent disruption, whether or not corrosion in the main cables can be halted."

The Association of British Drivers said: "A second road crossing is long overdue. Current talk of not increasing existing capacity, of introducing inter-city tramcars and of providing for multi-occupancy cars simply ignores the requirement for better access to Edinburgh from Fife and the north and promotes politically driven, anti-car policies".
EARLY BLOW

STRONG winds caused delays on the Forth Road Bridge during the morning rush hour yesterday, with speed limits reduced to 40mph between 4:30am and 2:30pm. The crossing was closed to double-decker buses between 4:30am and 9:20am.
BUSINESSMAN
'Accident causes tailback past Dunfermline'

WILLIAM Smith, 54, contracts manager. Commutes from Kirkcaldy to office in Davidson's Mains, Edinburgh. Says trip can be done in 25 minutes..
Monday, 13 November

I set off at 6:45am intent on an early start to the week, but tailback starts before Pitreavie junction. Into office at 8:25am.

Total time: 1 hour 40 minutes.
Tuesday, 14 November

Hoping to slip over at the back of the rush, I leave at 7:30am. Tailback at Rosyth. Arrive for a meeting at the South Gyle at 8:30am.

Total time: 1 hour.
Wednesday, 15 November

Leave home at 6:30am; still no luck. Traffic backed up to Pitreavie. But it moves quicker and I reach work at 7:20am.

Total time: 50 minutes.
Thursday, 16 November

Leave home at 7:15am - yet another day of slow-moving traffic. I arrive at 8:45am.

Total time: 1 hour 30 minutes.
Friday, 17 November

Away in Sunderland on business, after leaving last night.
Monday, 20 November

Leave at 7:35am. Accident causes a tailback past Dunfermline. Hit Edinburgh 9:15am.

Total time: 1 hour 40 minutes.
THE BUS USER
'Speed on the bridge restricted. It puts extra time on journey'

LYNSAY Copland, 22, a service representative, commutes by car from Cowdenbeath to Ferrytoll park and ride and from there to St Andrew Square bus station. She says that without hold-ups, the journey can be completed in 40 minutes.
Tuesday, 14 November

This morning traffic is heavy and slow. I am held up getting through Inverkeithing. Trying to get over the bridge at 7:15am takes about ten minutes as the road is heavily congested. Reach work at 8am.

Total time: 1 hour.
On the way home I catch the bus at 6:10 pm. I am caught in traffic from Dalmeny to the tolls. Speed on the bridge restricted to 40mph due to the weather. It puts an extra 15 minutes on my journey.
Total time: 50 minutes.
Wednesday, 15 November

I leave home at 6:40am and am held up from the Admiralty junction for five minutes; however when entering the motorway from Admiralty, a slip road into the park and ride from this junction means I make it to the park and ride in five minutes. Once on the bus the bridge traffic is moving relatively slowly, taking ten minutes to cross. Arrive at work at 8:10am.

Total time: 1 hour 30 minutes

Slightly later coming home this evening as I didn't catch the bus until 7:10. Traffic non-existent. I cross the bridge in five minutes and am home by 7:50pm.
Total time: 40 minutes.
Thursday, 16 November

Drive is less congested. Journey over the bridge much more free flowing. I reach work at 7:40.
Total time: 55 minutes.
THE MANAGER
'Weather is awful, I dread today's crossing'

LAWRENCE Robertson, 33, a commercial manager, lives in Dunfermline and works in Edinburgh city centre. At the quietest times his commute takes just 25 minutes.
Monday, 13 November

There are two ways to approach the bridge crossing - either go early or go late. Anywhere in between and you resign yourself to a minimum of a one hour journey for the 14-mile trip.Today, I decide on the late option, leaving Dunfermline at 8:25am.

However, I soon realise that this option won't work today. I wait for approximately 20 minutes to cross the bridge; I think the delay is simply down to the inclement weather. Once clear, my route is fine and I arrive at my office for 9:15am.

Total time: 50 minutes.
Tuesday, 14 November

I try to make it out the door earlier today, 8:10am, but again the weather is beating us. Strong winds and rain always cause delays, something that I can't quite understand but, alas, I join the queue two miles north of the bridge and wait the obligatory 20 minutes to cross.

It gives me time to reflect on the days in the summer when I can leave at the same time and due to the massive reduction in traffic due to the schools being out, I can be in in 25 minutes. Again, after small delays on my way in, I arrive at 8:55am.

Total time: 45 minutes.
Wednesday, 15 November

This time I do go early - leaving the house at 7am. As I approach the slip road at Rosyth I see the pleasing sight of cars moving at speed down the M90.

I join the slip road and make my way up onto the motorway to find that, even at this time in the morning, there are still delays.

The difference, though, is we keep moving and are clear of the bridge in no time at all.

Total time: 40 minutes.
Thursday and Friday, 16 and 17 November.

Two days off for me, as a business trip takes me to Leeds and the comfort of Scotrail and GNER to cross the bridge.
Monday, 20 November

I resolve to leave at 7:15am. The weather is awful and I dread today's crossing.

My fears are realised almost yards down the road when already a good mile and a half short of the ramp, we're queuing - this is the worst I've seen it, ever!

I await radio reports to confirm a collision, but again, we are simply looking at the weather, bridge restrictions and sheer volume of traffic.

I consider dumping the car and catching the train - but again resolve to sit in, enjoy BBC Five Live as my companion, and simply wait.

Total time: 1 hour 15 minutes.

In writing the diaries, I consider what other options are available to ease the crossing.

Another bridge? Not sure. Perhaps we can look at having three lanes crossing southwards in the morning and likewise coming back in the evening.

At the end of the day, none of us in Fife can really have cause to complain about the bridge as we made the decision to live there and must pay the consequences.

The rail link is frequent and on the whole reliable - but for most of us we simply enjoy the comforts of our own car and the radio for company.

Especially on cold days such as these, when the walk to and from the railway station would simply not be pleasant.

_________________
Paul Smith
Our scrap speed cameras petition got over 28,000 sigs
The Safe Speed campaign demands a return to intelligent road safety


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 1 post ] 

All times are UTC [ DST ]


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You can post attachments in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
[ Time : 0.010s | 10 Queries | GZIP : Off ]