Safe Speed Forums

The campaign for genuine road safety
It is currently Sat Nov 21, 2026 16:46

All times are UTC [ DST ]




Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 12 posts ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: Tue Nov 28, 2006 19:12 
Offline
Site Admin
User avatar

Joined: Sat Mar 06, 2004 06:46
Posts: 16903
Location: Safe Speed
mega link

Do speed cameras save lives on Merseyside?

Nov 28 2006

Life-savers or an unfair tax on hard-pressed motorists? David Higgerson looks for answers

by David Higgerson, Liverpool Daily Post

IT IS an issue which so divides people into either one camp or another that each has its own name for them. For road safety campaigners and those who live near roads where people regularly break the speed limit, the machines at the centre of this debate are "safety cameras".

For drivers and those who see them as an easy way for the Government to get even more tax revenue out of motorists, they are "speed cameras".

But regardless of which camp you fall into, there is one inescapable truth: the number of drivers they catch breaking the speed limit is about to rocket.

We revealed on Friday how the Merseyside Road Safety Camera Partnership expects to have issued 70,000 speeding tickets by the end of the current financial year - March, 2007.

That's up from just over 18,000 for the year ending March, 2006, the first full 12 months the partnership had been in operation.

Merseyside was relatively late joining the camera partnership initiative, the premise being that all costs in administering a beefed-up speed enforcement system are covered by the fines. Any excess goes to the Treasury.

In Lancashire, one of the first areas to create a council/police camera partnership, the number of tickets issued rocketed after the number of cameras increased dramatically. Up to £6m is now paid each year in speed fines, most of which goes to Chancellor Gordon Brown.

In Merseyside, however, the rise in tickets being issued this year is expected to be partly due to the fact even minor infringements are being punished after the "threshold" for prosecution was reduced.

Existing cameras are also being upgraded to take digital rather than film images, meaning they can store more pictures of speeding vehicles. And from next year, even drivers caught making the most minor breaches will be offered £90 speed awareness courses instead of three points and a £60 fine.

The Merseyside camera partnership points to a 42% reduction in deaths or serious injury in the last year at existing camera sites. Opposition campaigners, however, say cameras just move the problem elsewhere.

Today, the Daily Post asks the question: DO speed cameras save lives?


Scrap them all now - they're a deadly mistake

NO: Paul Smith, founder of the Safe Speed road safety campaign

WE'VE got safer cars and better roads than ever before. More air ambulances and better trained paramedics. Substantial efforts to treat crash blackspots. But road deaths haven't fallen as expected. In fact they are hardly falling at all. Transport Research Laboratory says this can only be because drivers are getting worse at avoiding crashes.

I believe that drivers are worsening because of bad road safety policy founded on speed cameras. One cause of the problem is that policy makers have focussed on crashes and have forgotten to consider how safe driving works.

Crashes are really very rare. With over 32 million licensed drivers and about 200,000 injury crashes each year, the average driver goes 160 years before he causes an injury crash. We need to look at how he manages not to cause injury for 160 years when if he stopped paying attention for just 20 seconds a crash would be a virtual certainty.

This is only the tip of the iceberg, but every single claim that's being made in support of the speed camera programme is provably wrong. For example, they claim that crashes are down at speed camera sites, but their claims are comprehensively undermined because they have neglected a "selection bias" that massively exaggerates the claimed benefit. But even if crashes were down at speed camera sites that wouldn't mean that cameras had made the roads safer because of the wider negative side effects that apply to the wider road network.

And the side effects are terrible. Just the damage to the relationship between police and public alone is enough to offset the entire benefit that Department for Transport is claiming for speed cameras. And that's one side effect out of around 30. Others include diverting driver attention from the road ahead, tending to de-skill the driving process, replacing genuine life-saving policies, distorting safety priorities and even slowing the rate at which drivers gain valuable experience.

The side effect that worries me most is the false safety message that makes many drivers think their speed must be safe if they are not exceeding the speed limit. Some of us are coming to regard the speedometer as a barometer of safety when of course it's no such thing. In fact, if your speedo stops working, you'll still be able to drive perfectly safely. And if you don't need a speedo at all to drive safely, how can the number it shows be important?

Speed cameras will go down in history as a deadly mistake. Road deaths aren't falling as expected. The British Medical Journal reports that hospitalisations of road crash victims have risen slightly over the last decade.

We must scrap all speed cameras now. It's the only way to get road safety back on track.


They save lives and are only used where needed

YES: Riverside MP Louise Ellman, a member of Parliament's Transport Select Committee

IN THE first eight months of this year, 391 people were either killed or seriously injured on Merseyside roads.

There have been 265 road deaths on Liverpool roads alone in the last two years.

Though that figure has reduced, it is still too high and it is an inescapable fact that speed cameras reduce the number of accidents. They save lives.

Reports show that motorists reduce their speeds by up to 70% at new fixed camera sites.

Every 1mph reduction in average speed will reduce crashes by 2-7%.

In 1994, 69% of drivers exceeded the 30mph limit, but by 2005 that figure has come down 50%.

Much of this has been achieved by the use of speed cameras. Reports show there is a huge amount of public support for cameras, despite the vocal campaigns against them.

Campaigners say they are just a money-making tool for the Government and the police, but this is not the case.

The money they make fund more cameras and go towards other road safety initiatives.

They are only used where there is a need for them.

Reports show 42% fewer people are killed or seriously injured in crashes at sites which have fixed speed cameras.

They prevent deaths and, at the end of the day, this matters more than anything else.

At the moment, speed cameras are placed where there have been a certain number of serious accidents and people have been killed.

The Parliament Transport Select Committee says that we shouldn't have to wait for someone to die on a road before a speed camera is placed there.

Excessive speed should be the only evidence needed to get these safety measures in place. The deaths can be prevented in the first place.

The committee feels there is a need for better technology to develop the benefits of speed cameras.

For example, time/distance cameras would mean speed limits could be enforced with cameras in 20mph zones.

This would make residential streets safer for pedestrians.

More accurate cameras and speedometers would allow police to lower the enforcement speed, which is currently 35mph, which would save even more lives.

It has been proved that a motorist's chances of survival halves if they are involved in a collision at 35mph, compared to a collision at 30mph.

All the evidence shows that speed cameras save lives.

But they are not the only way to prevent accidents. Equally vital is to have a more visible police presence on the roads.

Over the past 10 years, the number of officers patrolling our Merseyside roads has dropped from 354 to 178.

_________________
Paul Smith
Our scrap speed cameras petition got over 28,000 sigs
The Safe Speed campaign demands a return to intelligent road safety


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
PostPosted: Tue Nov 28, 2006 20:38 
Offline
User

Joined: Wed Mar 10, 2004 15:05
Posts: 1225
Location: Glasgow
SafeSpeed wrote:
Crashes are really very rare. With over 32 million licensed drivers and about 200,000 injury crashes each year, the average driver goes 160 years before he causes an injury crash.


I know it's a figure you use a lot, Paul, but many people who don't think too hard or aren't very good at arithmetic will read that and dismiss you, thinking that you are talking nonsense.

Is there another way you could express the same statistic?


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
PostPosted: Wed Nov 29, 2006 00:01 
Offline
Site Admin
User avatar

Joined: Sat Mar 06, 2004 06:46
Posts: 16903
Location: Safe Speed
r11co wrote:
SafeSpeed wrote:
Crashes are really very rare. With over 32 million licensed drivers and about 200,000 injury crashes each year, the average driver goes 160 years before he causes an injury crash.


I know it's a figure you use a lot, Paul, but many people who don't think too hard or aren't very good at arithmetic will read that and dismiss you, thinking that you are talking nonsense.

Is there another way you could express the same statistic?


I can use sound bites to try to win the minds of the innumerate, but I cannot ignore the numerate who will ultimately win the pub argument.

It's really my job to hand out ammunition. That means all kinds of ammunition. If some folk don't like land mines, then I'm afraid that's tough.

But I'm always open to new weapons.

_________________
Paul Smith
Our scrap speed cameras petition got over 28,000 sigs
The Safe Speed campaign demands a return to intelligent road safety


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Wed Nov 29, 2006 01:27 
Offline
Gold Member
Gold Member

Joined: Sun Aug 06, 2006 09:13
Posts: 771
Paul - great response & I think avoiding using "RTTM" helps simplify the argument. I like the 160 year example.

Would have liked to see more made of the 5% contributory factor though - in itself if that one is used properly it completely rubbishes the 42%.


Quote:
Reports show that motorists reduce their speeds by up to 70% at new fixed camera sites.


Interesting that she's used "new", I haven't seen that one before.

Quote:
Every 1mph reduction in average speed will reduce crashes by 2-7%.


Great maths - so just a 1mph reduction and every single crash caused by exceeding the limit will be solved!

Quote:
In 1994, 69% of drivers exceeded the 30mph limit, but by 2005 that figure has come down 50%.


How do they measure this - looks like rubbish to me (unless of course they measure the speed on the M6 or M25!

Quote:
Reports show 42% fewer people are killed or seriously injured in crashes at sites which have fixed speed cameras.


We really need to find a way of stopping them using this one completely out of context - is there any way of forcing a explanation on this magical 42% that appears everywhere?

_________________
Wake me up when the revolution starts
STOP the Toll Tax http://www.traveltax.org.uk


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Wed Nov 29, 2006 01:30 
Offline
Member
Member

Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 00:11
Posts: 764
Location: Sofa
How about
Quote:
the average driver would need a driving career spanning 160 years before he or she would cause an injury crash
or something along those lines?

_________________
Less Kodak, more Kojak.
In times of deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act.


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Wed Nov 29, 2006 01:50 
Offline
Site Admin
User avatar

Joined: Sat Mar 06, 2004 06:46
Posts: 16903
Location: Safe Speed
Graeme wrote:
Paul - great response & I think avoiding using "RTTM" helps simplify the argument. I like the 160 year example.

Would have liked to see more made of the 5% contributory factor though - in itself if that one is used properly it completely rubbishes the 42%.


Ha! The bloody article took 40 minutes to write, and then 8 hours of agony cutting it down to the 475 words allowed. :hehe:

A 'proper' argument can't really be constructed in under about 4,000 words.

_________________
Paul Smith
Our scrap speed cameras petition got over 28,000 sigs
The Safe Speed campaign demands a return to intelligent road safety


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
PostPosted: Wed Nov 29, 2006 02:37 
Offline
User
User avatar

Joined: Thu Apr 28, 2005 00:01
Posts: 2258
Location: South Wales
SafeSpeed wrote:
mega linkIt has been proved that a motorist's chances of survival halves if they are involved in a collision at 35mph, compared to a collision at 30mph.


WTF? Surely this is obviously wrong.

She explictly states motorist, ie someone in a car (as opposed to motorcyclist, cyclist or pedestrian)

Can we have some figures for this. I would guess that your chances of survival in a 30mph crash if you're in a car are very close to 100%

So at 35mph, almost half of people driving cars are killed? Somehow I don't think so.

(also this forum needs a smoking crack smiley)


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
PostPosted: Wed Nov 29, 2006 03:21 
Offline
Site Admin
User avatar

Joined: Sat Mar 06, 2004 06:46
Posts: 16903
Location: Safe Speed
Lum wrote:
SafeSpeed wrote:
mega linkIt has been proved that a motorist's chances of survival halves if they are involved in a collision at 35mph, compared to a collision at 30mph.


WTF? Surely this is obviously wrong.


No, it's about right. But it is positively misleading.

We have the Joksch 'rule of thumb' which looks like this:

- probability of death affecting a driver = (speed /71)^4

=> at 30mph = 3.2%
=> at 35mph = 5.9%

But let's be VERY clear about what we're talking about. We're not talking about free travelling speed. We're not even talking about impact speed. What we are talking about is called 'crash delta v' or change in speed during impact.

If the rule of thumb is correct, and I believe that it's close enough, we can use the equation backwards to find average crash delta v from the proportion of drivers who die in impacts. See http://www.safespeed.org.uk/12mph.html

Clearly across the entire road network including all speed limits and all vehicles including speeding vehicles average crash delta v is no greater than 12mph.

So the system isn't working anywhere near the point where the original claim applies. That's because we slow down in areas of danger and brake before impact.

_________________
Paul Smith
Our scrap speed cameras petition got over 28,000 sigs
The Safe Speed campaign demands a return to intelligent road safety


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
PostPosted: Wed Nov 29, 2006 14:46 
Offline
User
User avatar

Joined: Thu Apr 28, 2005 00:01
Posts: 2258
Location: South Wales
SafeSpeed wrote:
No, it's about right. But it is positively misleading.

We have the Joksch 'rule of thumb' which looks like this:

- probability of death affecting a driver = (speed /71)^4

=> at 30mph = 3.2%
=> at 35mph = 5.9%


No, I still maintain that it is wrong.

If she had said "the chance of death doubles from 30 -> 35mph" then that would be about right.

This is not the same as the chances of survival halving. It is not even close.

At 30mph, 96.8% chance of survival
at 35mph, 94.1% chance of survival

So in reality the reduction of survival chances is very slight as to a halving, making that comment an outright lie.


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
PostPosted: Wed Nov 29, 2006 14:59 
Offline
Site Admin
User avatar

Joined: Sat Mar 06, 2004 06:46
Posts: 16903
Location: Safe Speed
Lum wrote:
No, I still maintain that it is wrong.

If she had said "the chance of death doubles from 30 -> 35mph" then that would be about right.


Yep. You're right. I missed that particular error. :thumbsup: Thanks.

_________________
Paul Smith
Our scrap speed cameras petition got over 28,000 sigs
The Safe Speed campaign demands a return to intelligent road safety


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Wed Nov 29, 2006 20:34 
Offline
Gold Member
Gold Member

Joined: Thu Nov 09, 2006 14:06
Posts: 3654
Location: Oxfordshire
Even if she had said that she'd still be about 10% out :P

What pisses me off is the way in which the speed camera proponents will happily use soundbites to make "their case", and the innumerate/ill-informed/apathetic will swallow them at face value, despite them not standing up to even mild scrutiny!

Quote:
Though that figure has reduced, it is still too high and it is an inescapable fact that speed cameras reduce the number of accidents. They save lives.

Reports show that motorists reduce their speeds by up to 70% at new fixed camera sites.


Suggesting here that reducing speed through a camera site saves lives! Moreover, she's got her maths pretty screwy again! If motorists reduced their speed by up to 70% that would mean that prior to the camera arriving at a 30, some people were doing 100 on that stretch of road, if it was a 40, then they must have been doing over 130!!! It's a meaningless bluster with an arbitrary number thrown in for 'credibility'!! Not good enough from an elected official!!!!! :x

Quote:
In 1994, 69% of drivers exceeded the 30mph limit, but by 2005 that figure has come down 50%.


If 50% are still breaking it then its waaay lower than the 85%ile!!!

So far she hasn't mentioned how scameras are 'saving lives', purely that they make people slow down! NO SH*T!!

Quote:
Reports show 42% fewer people are killed or seriously injured in crashes at sites which have fixed speed cameras.


Has some (grossly expensive) government survey determined that '42%' is the bogus statistic most likely to be believed by the general public or something?! Has this woman even read into the debate, or is she just pulling numbers from her side's argument to accompany any fact she pleases?

Quote:
All the evidence shows that speed cameras save lives.


She hasn't produced any evidence thus far, lets see if she does...

Quote:
Over the past 10 years, the number of officers patrolling our Merseyside roads has dropped from 354 to 178.


Nope!

When polititians are uncovered lying to their electorate, should they not resign?


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
 Post subject:
PostPosted: Thu Nov 30, 2006 11:13 
Offline
Life Member
Life Member
User avatar

Joined: Wed Apr 13, 2005 14:00
Posts: 1271
Location: Near Telford, UK / Barcelona, Spain
RobinXe wrote:
Has some (grossly expensive) government survey determined that '42%' is the bogus statistic most likely to be believed by the general public or something?!

42 is, of course, "The Answer to Life, The Universe and Everything" (according to the late Douglas Adams anyway).

RobinXe wrote:
When polititians are uncovered lying to their electorate, should they not resign?

The House of Commons would be like a ghost town! :twisted:

_________________
"Politicians are the same the world over... We build bridges where there aren't any rivers." - Nikita Kruschev


Top
 Profile Send private message  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 12 posts ] 

All times are UTC [ DST ]


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 59 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You can post attachments in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
[ Time : 0.025s | 11 Queries | GZIP : Off ]