Odin wrote:
So is it always or probably? Please make up your mind!
"Pretty much always" does not equal "always" Odin.
I will stick my head on the line though and say I don't remember seeing anybody u-turn out of a line of traffic carefully, it's a last resort thing, the person is angry at being stuck, wants to get out; this generally results in sudden movements, failure to do normal mirror checks, failure to indicate before the manouvre and a release of built up aggression which normally translates to bad driving.
Anybody a bit chilled out probably isn't actually going to try and u-turn out of the line, or shoot down a left hand turn.
I will add that sometimes people in cars will PURPOSFULLY pull out to squeeze a "filtering" cyclist or motorcyclist, I've got testimonials from both groups of riders on that one.
Odin wrote:
Is this in addition to keeping an eye on the speedo and an eye on the road, oops sorry, I forgot, you don't move your eyes do you. And how do you know what the driver is thinking and why he is doing it. What statistical measures have you taken other than noting 3 or 4 cars doing this in your driving career.
Three or four cars in my driving career!!! Ha ha!
I ride a push bike in London, I see people swinging out of queues left and right nearly every day, taxi drivers are great at it; normally brilliant drivers but when it comes to u-turns they are often like sharks, roll eyes back in head and commit!
Front wheel movement to the left or right is normally the first sign somebody is going to make a break for it, either that or they don't move forward when the queue moves forward, and then they might dart out using the space in front they've created for themselves.
Odin wrote:
Again you continue to resort to meaningless arbitrary numbers, so would you still maintain the same, if say the lane of traffic you were filtering past was doing 55mph on the motorway? I'd say that 15mph was pretty suicidal in that instance wouldn't you?
Er, we're talking stationary queues here.
How fast would you pass down the outside or inside of a lane of stationary cars from about a two metres away on a motorbike? If it's faster than about 15mph, er, you're a suicidal manic, and 15mph is probably too fast.
Odin wrote:
That was the op's point [sometimes people do swing out without thinking], and who was liable in this instance.
Doens't matter does it. If you're going to chortle down the outisde of a stationary line of traffic and not ASSUME somebody is going to sharply pull out to u-turn right in front of you or fling a door open, and you're on two wheels then it doesn't matter who's fault it is, you're going to be on the floor, so the slower you're going (or the further away from the cars) the better.
Defensive driving/riding is the key; assume it's going to happen because you might not be around to blame the other person for not looking after you've gone through the passenger window of their vehicle.
Chucking down a stationary line of traffic though at a speed that means if somebody does nose out of it means you're going to hit them is bordering on careless/dangerous driving, of which both parties in a collision can be guilty of.
Here's quite a good round up on the topic: -
http://www.motorcycle-training.f2s.com/filtering.html