Tentatively joining the thread, prepared for the flames:
I dunno about you guys but I fear for my car/bike much more than for my body
(the first thing a real cyclist will say after a crash: “is my bike ok?”)
Wearing a helmet doesn’t change my riding style, instead my anticipated ride defines whether I want to wear a helmet. If I’m doing scary off-roading then I’ll happily wear a helmet; if pottering around then I won’t bother. This goes some way to supporting the idea of “risk compensation” in this instance.
To say “a cyclist wearing a helmet would be more experienced” is absolute rubbish. It could be a newbie who doesn’t yet appreciate the risks involved and won’t chance it.
I personally appreciate the principle that lack of seatbelt use could encourage greater caution but only to a point. When younger, I was given a lift by someone who had bought himself a ‘classic’ car, meaning it had no seatbelts. I was s**ting myself but he thought nothing of it and it clearly didn’t temper his driving style - I never rode with him again. However, for me that was a one off, for him it was already normal; he had become complacent. Long term complacency is a significant factor, resulting with the extra risk being forgotten and eventually no-longer being factored into the decision making process. There’s no way anyone could convince me that driver wasn’t statistically at more risk of becoming a statistic.
I admit it - I have done the occasional (very very short) trip without the seatbelt and yes it did make me more aware of my personal safety, but I believe I would eventually forget about it and revert back to my usual driving attitude if I decided to go permanently without.
“Maintaining a level of risk you are comfortable with” (risk compensation) is absolute rubbish when applied to seatbelt usage. I control a machine that could so instantly and easily become a lethal weapon,
lethal to others as well as myself. I have a social conscience, this means I respect other road users (pedestrians, cyclists, drivers). When I’m behind the wheel I’m acutely aware that I pose
at least as much risk to others than I do to myself. I absolutely do not want to be the reason why their family, friends, relatives to lose a loved one; I can live with injuring/killing myself but not others (no pun intended). Lack of use of my seatbelt does not reduce the risk to others, hence I don’t accept my driving style will depend significantly on seatbelt use. I believe this will apply to the majority of drivers.
That Risk Homeostasis theory doesn’t address long term complacency; it also doesn’t properly address cause and effect when drawing individual conclusions “
So is it that healthy people cycle? Or cycling makes people healthy?”{PS}; it can’t say with confidence that seatbelts are ineffective, it also doesn’t account for other factors such as the subsequent reduction of driver skill and trafpol because of the rise of other forms of enforcement.
Conclusion: to say that XXX is not effective because YYY didn’t occur/abate is useless because, like so many other studies, the factors in question are considered in isolation while overlooking subtle yet critical factors' like time – just like RTTM (time dependent) and ‘bias on selection’ when considering speed camera effectiveness.
Either way I’m ‘anti-compulsion’ but for ‘informed decision’