Trouble is - they are too subjective and emotional.
Fortunately - the Law may be as ass at times - but at least it is an objective one!
And do you know - for every one case they appear to get wrong - they get the remaining 99 banged to rights really.
This was one of them. They prosecuted quickly for the defective tyres They gave the correct penalty. I understand one tyre was just borderline after chatting to a pal "a bit more in the know" on this. Seems to explain the 6 points then.
Case is not closed. This is still under scrutiny and thus a bit silly for some to make such emotional statements as quoted in all press reports. To make such comments when all facts are not known could prejudice any further court case to address this affair. Why I think they would do better to have commented that justice was served over the defective tyres and that hopefully all involved will get answers, justice and closure eventually as the "truth will always out."
But regardless - that driver is hurting just as much as the victims. These people - Amy and Mary - they have not seen the sheer shock, grief, guilt, fear on faces of drivers and others involved in incidents - victim or person causing collision. I have - and I would say that the trauma for all is very much equal for these human beings - and I worry that these hostile over -emotional outbursts dehumanise and even unfairly "demonise" those involved and feed very untrue myths about the dangers of cycling.
This incident was one of the nightmare incidents in which no one was to blame. Mad Doc and Wildy and rest of this family felt anger in the case of Ferdl, resignatiion in the case of Rudi who died when the jumbo he was in plummeted into the sea - a loss they really felt because there was no body and the family still burn an eternal candle on the family grave in Appenzell for him. They ended up forgiving the driver who killed Ferdl - he tried to kill himself. To them - the fact that that driver feels such remorse means Ferdl's memory lives on beyond the circle of family and friends.
In Wildy's case. Guy was ill. He knew he was ill. His wife tried to persuade him not to go to work that fatal morning. Wildy, like these riders, like Mr Harris, like Ferdl, like Rudi.. wrong place .. wrong time.

But still Wildy was helpless. She could not get out of the way. He may have felt "under the weather" but - well - you do not expect to just begin to die when on a motorway like that.
Of course the Mad Doc was hurt and angry. Kriss was very deeply upset - even more hurt than the Mad Doc - as were Wildy's two brothers. My brothers, sister and other police - gendarme/Canadian also over -reacted. We very unprofessionally pulled people for the slightest percieved infringement. For a couple of months - I would have rightly been described as the jobsworthy cop from hell.
In the meantime as Wildy herself posted on this site - the widow suffered. She kept sending Wildy flowers and Wildy initially returned them as this served only to remind her of the incident. Wildy posted some time ago that this widow tried to kill herself. Blamed herself for not stopping he husband.. not taking the car keys and hiding them. Mad Cats immediately gave her support and even secured her insurance pay-out when fighting the sharks who orginally insured the deceased.
So I guess I am trying to say that it is wrong to keep blaming this driver. As for various comments that he should not have driven in "such adverse conditions".
Well- as I recall the day was cold but dry and failry bright. A sunny winter day. I think I went for a walk or a ride with my own kids that day.
But if people want to argue that the driver should not have been driving in such adverse conditions, then by that same logic (and this does in no way reflect on the cycling club at all - it is simply pointing out the lack of logic) - but we have an organised ride... one which requires a HSE risk assessment and if the weather conditions were so adverse that a driver should have thought twice - then so too should the cycling club and anyone else travelling anywhere on that very cold, but hazy sunny and wintry day.
But then - the riders could not have foreseen a patch of lethal black ice any more than the driver.
Thus - tragic incident and one hopes true medical and professional help is given to all involved.
For record - all on this site would extend sincere and heartfelt sympathy for everyone involved in this incident.